Yesterday, Today and Tomorrow (iA)

AsSalamuAlaikum and AhlanWaSahlan... Welcome To My Head - My World...

Tuesday, June 28, 2005

Islam being 'hijacked'??

(This is a letter written by a reader to the local newspaper that I found interesting)

Muslims have often complained of Islam being hijacked by a minority of fanatical followers, bent on waging a holy war against 'The West'. If Muslims feel that way, then they have only themselves to blame for leaving the door wide open and falling asleep.

A short while back, Canadian-based Irshad Manji published what was hoped to be the ultimate controversy in the North American Islamic Community. In her book, 'The Trouble with Islam', Irshad stressed 'reformation' ideas that seemed to revolve mostly on agitating practicing Muslims, rather than genuinely proposing any change.

After the book-launching and promotional kick-offs, her publishers had hoped for a much anticipated public backlash, Muslims burning her books, rallies and riots. Much to their disappointment, there was not so much as a momentary yawn from the Muslim community, conferences where the turn out was so small that they had to be cancelled, and community leaders who did not have the time of day to accept several invitations from Irshad Manji to debate on talk shows.

Muslims in North America have learnt that in such times, riots and rallies only serve the cause of extremists such as Irshad Manji, and the best way to deal with them is to counter their arguments with silence. At the same time, a thorough self-study of what reality is, so that we have answers to give to our children who are approached by the filth strewn from the likes of Irshad.

When we do not educate ourselves on Islam and put it into practice, we allow all elements of extermism - both from the left and the right - to take over the empty stage.

- Zeeshan Dogar, Mississauga, Ontario, Cananda

7 Comments:

  • At Tuesday, June 28, 2005 11:12:00 PM, Blogger Ninnevah said…

    i remember in the summer when she came down to Melbourne for her book release, there was an islamic conference organized on the same night for dr. Zakir Naik at one of the largest lecture theatres at Melbourne university...so you can guess where the majority of the muslims attended...but the next day both speakers where mentioned in the same article highlighting the two "extremes" of Islam....even tho i dont agree dr. Zakir Naik is
    right to be represented as an extremist, i do beleive she is, but just in the wrong direction...

     
  • At Thursday, June 30, 2005 11:48:00 AM, Blogger Abu Yusef said…

    Interesting letter.

    The age of mass protests is over. Protests get general media publicity, but if Muslims really want to be heard and to counter those that we disagree with (or support those we agree with) the internet is the forum of the future. While anyone can post anything on the internet inteligent people will always be able to distinguish well thought out and researched ideas vs opinions with little basis.

    Salaam
    Abu Yusef

     
  • At Thursday, June 30, 2005 5:06:00 PM, Blogger Blue Rose said…

    The problem with the net is, that there is too much to sift through before you reach/find something useful or worthwhile. Also, it is very hard to distinguish what the right is from the wrong. In fact, the 'right' almost no longer exists. All you find is a twisted and very much deviated form of it. It is very hard to find your way through all of this without getting lost.

     
  • At Thursday, June 30, 2005 6:10:00 PM, Blogger Abu Yusef said…

    Blue rose,
    you are very correct...
    But what I am really saying is that protests have organizers... charasmatic individuals who have a point, and a specific issue. Others who agree then attend the protests they initiate.

    There are spokes people and more reputable sites that could be used to get a message out while the news media (regardless of its origin) will never actually say what the details of protesters positions are (if they have any which is sometimes the problem with protests they are sometimes just to general)

    What if you combine web and protests. The organizer makes a website or states a position that the protesters generally agree with... and all the protesters make sure they put the URL at the top of whatever their sign is so that the actual message of the protest can get out. As long as every sign does this than anyone viewing the news will have access to the positions of the organization without filtering... and there will be no way to warp a message... By either corrupt state run medias, or corporate media.

    Just a thought.

    Salaam
    Abu Yusef

     
  • At Thursday, June 30, 2005 8:15:00 PM, Blogger Blue Rose said…

    The idea is a very pleasant one if it were practical.

    And I wish it would be.

    InshaAllah, maybe we might get to see something along those lines in the near future?

     
  • At Thursday, June 30, 2005 9:40:00 PM, Blogger Ninnevah said…

    but even if that were practical i dont think all these ppl protesting would agree on the one site...which site to be representative of their arguement/stand.

    i dont really agree with that about internet, its more like whoever is louder is heard, same with websites.

     
  • At Friday, July 01, 2005 12:23:00 PM, Blogger Blue Rose said…

    Not exactly. If you are a good computer geek, and you know your advertising skills well, even you or me can be the owner of the 'most' popular website. Its all too easy.

    Although like I said previously, it will be difficult for the reader to chose one amongst zillions.

    In real life, you have to be strong and loud to be heard by the masses. Hence, the listeners have a smaller population to chose from. One in thousands?

     

Post a Comment

<< Home